THW: Triple Crown Sweep Unlikely

THE HOARSE WHISPERER By Jenny Ortuoste for Manila Standard-Today,  28 April 2010, Wednesday

Triple Crown Sweep Unlikely

It’s a sign that Philippine breeding is improving and racing becoming more competitive, with the lack of a sure contender for three-year-old honors in the summer’s Triple Crown competition.

The Philippine Racing Commission-sponsored trilogy of races showcases elite 3YO local-breds. In years past, there would always be one or two runners who clearly outclassed the rest – Fair and Square, Sun Dancer, and Real Top, to name a few. But since Silver Story did it in 2001, no horse has swept all three legs of the event.

A sweep is now considered rare enough for the Philracom to offer a P500,000 bonus prize to whoever achieves it. This year, it seems like the purse will go unclaimed once again.

Over the past few weeks, horses nominated for the Triple Crown and its auxiliary race, the Hopeful Stakes, have been running in prep races. Among those who won their preps and are emerging as likely favorites are Consolidator and Yes Pogi in the Triple Crown on May 9, and Lakota Creek, Thief in the Nite, Hot, and Queen of Class in the Hopeful on May 8, both at Santa Ana Park.

In mile races last weekend at Santa Ana Park, Eric Tagle’s Thief in the Nite ran wire-to-wire to win by five lengths, Sandy Javier’s Hot came from behind in an easy win, and Jun Almeda’s Consolidator destroyed the field to win by 13 lengths.

The latter’s impressive run tagged it as a likely favorite for the Triple Crown, yet Consolidator ran against a lesser field of Hopeful wannabes. It’ll be a different scenario come the actual race.

Gray filly Heaven Sent won the 2009 Triple Crown first leg.

Mirroring the openness of the local Triple Crown is the US version. Eskendereya, early favorite for the Kentucky Derby on May 1, was scratched the other day after incurring an injury. The “Run for the Roses”, first jewel of the US Triple Crown, is now anybody’s race.

An annual event since 1875, held on the first Saturday in May, the KY Derby attracts horseracing fans from all over the world, some dressed in their best outfits, others in their wackiest hats.

(Image from

They come to savor the mint juleps, engage in horse racing betting, and watch the finest horses in the country race for honors in one of the most historic and prestigious events in the world.

The field for this year’s edition includes: American Lion, Awesome Act, Conveyance, Dean’s Kitten, Devil May Care,   Discreetly Mine, Dublin, Endorsement, Homeboykris, Ice Box, Interactif, Jackson Bend, Line of David, Lookin at Lucky, Make Music For me, Mission Impazible, Noble’s Promise, Paddy O’Prado, Setsuko, Sidney’s Candy, Stately Victor, and Super Saver. (The scratches were Eskendereya, Rule, and Endorsement.)

Last year’s KY Derby was won by Mine that Bird with Calvin Borel on top. Rallying from last place, the tandem sneaked unnoticed by the rail, a tactic the jockey is known for, hence his nickname “Bo-rail”. Even the race announcer did not mention his name until he was three lengths in front and less than a hundred meters from the wire. The “monumental upset” was the second biggest in Derby history. This led to a surge in interest in Kentucky Derby betting.

This year, Bo-rail is riding Super Saver. However, it is the Bob Baffert-trained Lookin at Lucky that may be the likeliest contender, along with Sidney’s Candy who has beaten him before.

Lookin at Lucky, 2Y0 champion in 2009, started his 2010 season by winning the Rebel Stakes. He later placed third in the Santa Anita Derby. (Image from

Both here and in the US, the Triple Crown is up for grabs by the best – and the luckiest. Given a good break from the gate, a gap in the wall of horses, and a clear path to the wire, any of the competitors may gain the gold and the glory.

A sweep? Not likely, but it would be fantastic if it happens. In any case, going by the excellent quality of thoroughbreds nowadays, horseracing as a sport is the clear winner. And that’s as good as a sweep. ***

Related stories:

6 Comments on THW: Triple Crown Sweep Unlikely

  1. john turner
    30 April 2010 at 1:38 am (3691 days ago)

    Great article, Sidneys Candy for me. JT

  2. khyle
    30 April 2010 at 11:31 pm (3690 days ago)


  3. NiHAWmA
    1 May 2010 at 12:35 pm (3690 days ago)

    Pedigree’s credentials, past performances and post position is the key factor in selecting a winner. Todd Pletcher is fielding in 4 horses and is eyeing his first win.

    I still can not forget Mine That Bird and Pioneer of the Nile which was my second wager in the Triple Crown. Smarty Jones was my first wager.

    Here are my choices in Exacta, Trifecta and Superfecta including Win, place and show.

    LOOKIN AT LUCKY has a good chance and is occupying post position #1 while SIDNEY’S CANDY is in stall #20. Both of them had a good workouts in 5 furlongs.

    We should also keep an eye on AWESOME ACT, MISSION IMPAZIBLE, ICE BOX and LINE OF DAVID which I consider as longshot.

  4. NiHAWmA
    2 May 2010 at 11:23 am (3689 days ago)

    SUPER SAVER wins the derby with Calvin Borel (rider of Street Sense). His third win in the derby and the first ever for Todd Pletcher. Maria’s Mon now has sired two derby winners Super Saver and Monarchos. Super Saver has an AP Indy bloodline.

    LOOKIN AT LUCKY (post position #1) was unlucky as he was jostled during the early going. A case of bad luck. Still went on to finish 6th.

    2010 Kentucky Derby official results (order of finish)

    Super Saver $18.80, $8.80, $6.00
    Ice Box $11.20, $8.00
    Paddy O’ Prado $7.40

    Exacta $152.40
    Trifecta $2,337
    Superfecta $202,569 (4th place finisher included)

    Make Music For Me
    Noble’s Promise
    Lookin At Lucky
    Simply Victor
    Mission Impazible
    Devil May Care ( the only filly)
    American Lion
    Jackson Bend
    Discreetly Mine
    Dean’s Kitten
    Sidney’s Candy
    Line of David
    Awesome Act

  5. khyle
    4 May 2010 at 2:20 am (3687 days ago)

    Hi Ms. Jen!

    I am so happy Super Saver won the Kentucky Derby! It was, as usual, the most thrilling 2-minute show ever, attended by lots of people cheering for their bets.

    Having said so, I hate to compare our version with theirs, but our TC lack the luster (and perhaps horse talent) of the US counterpart – by millions!

    As for our version: don’t you think that the Hopeful Stakes affect the main Triple Crown Race of having a full gate of starters (and other big stakes races)? We seldom see a huge field, thus diminishing excitement and better betting payoffs (and even the chances of longshots to win). With numerous runners, winning and running down the wire first becomes deeper and more challenging. More so, why not just withdraw the idea of having the Hopeful Stakes and relocate its prizes to increase the purse of major stakes races to attract more owners to participate their horses?

    Well, just a thought! :-)

  6. NiHAWmA
    18 May 2010 at 4:48 pm (3673 days ago)

    Being LUCKY is not a supertition. Lookin At Lucky had a great run that Super Saver had no excuses. The distance was tailor made for Super Saver. It’s going to be a different story come Belmont Stakes race.